SUPRACRICOID LARYNGECTOMY

Alejandro Castro & Javier Gavilán

Supracricoid laryngectomy consists of en bloc resection of both vocal cords, the paraglottic spaces and the thyroid cartilage (Figure 1). It was first described by Majer in 1959 1 and Piquet in 1974 2. It is used for the treatment of selected early and locally advanced glottic and transglottic carcinoma in an oncologically safe manner, while preserving laryngeal function i.e. swallowing (airway protection), breathing and phonation.

Fig 1 Fig 1
Figure 1: Typical supracricoid laryngectomy specimen

Indications and limitations

Supracricoid laryngectomy is used to treat glottic carcinoma affecting one/both vocal cords, including cancers with deep invasion of the paraglottic space and altered vocal cord mobility. The epiglottis and pre-epiglottic space can be included in the specimen, allowing for resection of transglottic tumours that invade the supraglottic and glottic regions. One arytenoid can also be resected. However combined resection of the epiglottis and one arytenoid usually results in poor functional outcomes and increases the chance for aspiration and delayed decannulation.

Types of supracricoid operations

With supracricoid laryngectomy the hyoid bone is approximated directly to the cricoid with three sutures (Figures 2a-c). Types of supracricoid laryngectomy are illustrated below i.e. cricohyoidoepiglottopexy (CHEP), cricohyoidopexy (CHP), and tracheocricohyoidoepiglottopexy (Figures 2a-c). With tracheocricohyoidoepiglottopexy the anterior cricoid is resected for an additional tumour margin anteriorly.

Fig 2
Figure 2: Cricohyoidoepiglottopexy (a), cricohy-oidopexy (b), and tracheocricohyoidoepi-glottopexy (c)

Function

Key functional outcomes are airway, phonation and swallowing without aspiration. Phonation and swallowing depend on the arytenoids being able to tilt forwards and make contact with the base of the tongue; to breathe the arytenoids tilt posteriorly to open the airway (Figures 3, 4).

Fig 3
Figure 3: Arytenoids tilt forwards and backwards for phonation, swallowing and breathing
Fig 4
Figure 4: Arytenoids tilt backwards and forwards for breathing, phonation, swallowing

Cricoarytenoid unit (Figures 5, 6)

An intact cricoarytenoid unit is critical for function. It comprises the arytenoid mounted on an intact posterior cricoid ring, with a functioning recurrent laryngeal nerve and lateral and posterior cricoarytenoid muscles. Ideally one should preserve both cricoarytenoid units; sacrificing one unit increases the chance of disabling aspiration in the cases where the epiglottis is resected.

Fig 5
Figure 5: Anatomy of the cricoarytenoid unit and the course of the recurrent laryngeal nerve (yellow arrow) directly behind the articular facet of the inferior cornu of the thyroid cartilage
Fig 6
Figure 6: Right side illustrates the situation after su-pracricoid laryngectomy with preserved cricoarytnoid unit

Preoperative Evaluation

Careful selection of candidates is the key to success of supracricoid laryngectomy. Both tumour and patient factors must be taken into account to ensure satisfactory oncologic and functional outcomes.

  1. Tumour factors

TNM classifications were not developed to guide the indications for different surgical techniques; other factors should be taken into account when considering supracricoid laryngectomy. In general, supracricoid laryngectomy is indicated for T1 and selected T2-3 glottic as well as selected T2-4a supraglottic cancers. Nevertheless supracricoid laryngectomy is usually appropriate, for example, for virtually any T2 glottic cancer but it is contraindicated for those rare T2 glottic cancers with extensive subglottic extension.

Two types of vocal cord immobility should be taken into account when considering supracricoid laryngectomy

The extent of the tumour relative to the resection limits of supracricoid laryngectomy must be considered

Careful preoperative evaluation should be undertaken to ensure that the primary tumour falls within these abovementioned limits. As a rule, indirect (fiberoptic) and/ or direct laryngoscopy are adequate for this purpose. CT scan or other imaging techniques may help in some cases, particularly to determine extralaryngeal extension through thyroid cartilage.

Extending the resection beyond the abovementioned parameters reduces the chance of functional success (aspiration and/or inability to be decannulated), and should be performed only in very carefully selected patients. Employing supracricoid laryngectomy with too advanced tumours, or relying on postoperative radiotherapy to treat positive margins is unacceptable as it increases recurrence rates and reduces survival.

Frozen section should always be used with any type of open partial laryngectomy. With supracricoid laryngectomy, it should be obtained to confirm oncologic safety of every close margin, and routinely at the level of the cricoid. Patients should agree preoperatively that total laryngectomy will be performed if negative margins cannot be obtained.

Neck dissection can be performed simultaneously. T1-2 glottic cancer without evidence of neck metastases can be treated with supracricoid laryngectomy without neck dissection. Elective ipsilateral neck dissection is advocated for locally advanced, purely glottic tumours (vocal cord fixation). Bilateral neck dissection is recommended in all patients with tumour invading the supraglottis regardless of T and N stage.

  1. Patient factors

Patients need to learn new ways to swallow after removal of part of the larynx. Every patient undergoing supracricoid laryngectomy will experience aspiration of varying degrees during the initial postoperative days.

Age is an important consideration as the brain’s plasticity decreases with age as does a patient’s ability to learn new swallowing techniques. Classically, 65-70yrs is considered the cut-off for open partial laryngectomy. However, a patient’s general status is more important than age itself, and successful results have been reported in older patients 5, 6.

Careful evaluation of comorbidities is important to ensure successful functional outcomes. The cough reflex is of critical importance to deal with aspiration. In our series, up to 15% of patients developed pneumonia 7. Pulmonary and cardiac reserve is crucial to overcome this complication. Some authors recommend routine preoperative pulmonary function tests 8, 9. We believe that a detailed clinical history is adequate, focusing attention on symptoms relating to chronic obstructive pulmonary disease e.g. dyspnoea when walking up a flight of stairs and types of medication.

Supracricoid laryngectomy operation

The operation is done under general anaesthesia with the patient in a supine position. Antibiotics are administered perioperatively.

  1.     Surgical approach

Fig 7
Figure 7: Infra- and suprahyoid muscles
Fig 8
Figure 8: Infra- and suprahyoid muscles
Fig 9
Figure 9: Divide sternohyoid muscle
Fig 10
Figure 10: Retract omohyoid and divide thyrohyoid muscle
Fig 11
Figure 11: Divide sternothyroid muscle
Fig 12
Figure 12: Surgical view of exposed larynx with strap muscles reflected. Thyroid lobes have been dissected and retracted laterally exposing the larynx and the first tracheal rings. Note that the anterior wall of the trachea has been dissected to facilitate cricohy-oidopexy at the end of the surgery
Fig 13
Figure 13: Divide superior laryngeal vessels
Fig 14
Figure 14: (Right side) Rotate the larynx with a hook placed at the posterior border of the thyroid cartilage and divide the lateral thyrohyoid ligament at its inser-tion on the superior cornu of the thyroid cartilage
Fig 15a
Figure 15a: Divide the inferior constrictor muscle. Traction on the muscle is generated by rotating the larynx with a hook placed at the posterior border of the thyroid cartilage. The dotted red line marks the course of the cut. Note that the cut turns anteriorly as it approaches the inferior cornu to protect the recur-rent laryngeal nerve
Fig 15b
Figure 15b: The inferior constrictor muscle has been divided over the lateral border of the right thyroid ala exposing the submucosa of the pyriform sinus
Fig 16
Figure 16: A suture is passed through the pyriform sinus submucosa
Fig 17
Figure 17: The larynx is rotated with a hook. The in-ferior cornu of the thyroid cartilage is divided with scissors taking the course of the recurrent laryngeal nerve (yellow line) into consideration
  1. Resecting the larynx

The supracricoid laryngectomy specimen is resected by means of two horizontal and two vertical cuts (Figure 18)

Fig 18
Figure 18: Horizontal and vertical cuts

Inferior horizontal cut

Fig 19a
Figure 19a: Surgical view of the inferior horizontal cut. Note that the endotracheal tube is still in place
Fig 19b
Figure 19b: Inferior horizontal cut (cricothyrotomy); the orotracheal tube is removed and a new tube is inserted through the cricothyrotomy

Superior horizontal cut

This can be made at two different levels, depending on the superior extension of the tumour

Fig 20a
Figure 20a: Superior horizontal cut for epiglottis-preserving approach. Scalpel is inserted in the midline immediately above the superior border of the thyroid cartilage
Fig 20b
Figure 20b: A cut is been made to one side
Fig 20c
Figure 20c: The cut is completed on the contralateral side
Fig 20d
Figure 20d: Surgical view of the superior horizontal cut. The mucosa is opened in the midline before the cut is completed Figure 20e: Arytenoids visible through superior horizontal cut